Sorry, but it had to be done.
Ann Widdecombe has become one of the most well known politicians over the past fifteen years. Forthright, outspoken, she has admirers and detractors alike. Like a no of people with the Labour Party, and indeed the Liberal Democrats, I have a lot of time for Ann Widdecombe and respect her, albeit heavily disagreeing with her at the same time.
So it was that I read
this blogpost describing in detail as to why she is a "nasty person". Widders is many things, but nasty is an accusation I think is unfair, so it was that I felt that this post needed a fisking.
She is anti-abortion and seems to have problems with embryonic stem cell research whilst not fully understanding the science behind it. Scientists didn’t want to create a human/animal hybrid Ann.
So are a no of Labour MP's, particularity those who are Roman Catholic. Understanding the science behind it or not is not the concern, it's the sanctity of life from conception but before birth that is why there is criticism of stem cell research
She is anti-Sex Education.
That is a very broad and sweeping point, and could do with some clarification
She supports Homophobia as long it’s by religious people (It’s free speech you know.)
Ann Widdecombe is also a friend of Iain Dale who not only holds her in admiration but is also gay. So perhaps homophobic is a sweeping accusation that needs clarification
She seems to think that the Church of England apologising for the Crusades and slavery “makes them look silly”.
I agree that the need to apologise for past atrocities is important, but I can see where Ann Widdecombe is coming from, i.e. should one apologise for something that neither you or your contemporaries are responsible for. That doesn't make her a nasty person, that simply means that she is not looking at the whole picture.
She believes in censorship.
What's wrong with that?
She is one of the idiot MP’s who wanted Terrorism suspects detained for42 days despite no evidence that it would help investigations in any way.
Again I agree that 42 days is excessive and prefer 28 days. But I can see where she, and other individual MP's from all sides of the House of Commons, are coming from! We live in a semi state of War, fighting terrorist groups who seek to aggressively destroy our way of life and that includes making innocent civilians targets. If you said she supported waterboarding, Guantamano Bay's history of operations on terrorism, or Kelvin Mackenzie's cretinous comment about 420 days, I would agree
She is against political parties trying to help get more women intoParliament.
That simply means that she feels that people should be elected to Parliament purely on merit
She insisted that Tories “throughout the Thatcher period” had always cared about the poor.
I see the point being made, but some Thatcherite Tories have outdated romanticised views of philanthropists coming in en masse when the state withdraws it's contribution. It just shows a naivety of human nature.
She writes for the Daily Express.
No, that just makes her naive. If I were to start having a go at people and regard them as nasty, simply for writing for a particular newspaper I detested (and the Daily Express is one of the newspapers I truly detest), then where would I stop?
She is a climate change denier.
Again, does that make her nasty! It just shows her to be ignorant of the facts. I know several pleasant people who are climate change deniers, I don't regard them as nasty, simply wrong on that issue.It's the overall views in general and the attitude that goes with it that makes me, and many others, regard someone as nasty or not!
She left the Church of England because they started ordinating woman.
Some interpretations of Scripture (and Ann Widdecombe is a believer) state that she may be right. I happen to disagree, both scripturally and morally, but given at how convincing a surface reading of The Bible can make regarding a negative view of the ordination of women, I feel sorry for her and those who share her views, I can't regard her as nasty for that. If she didn't want women in authority in all walks of life, then you may have a point.
Although on the plus side she is against fox hunting.
I agree on that, although there are some fairly unpleasant people who are pro foxhunting, and I like to keep some of my powder dry in dealing with them!
Labels: Ann Widdecombe, Fisking, Pickled Politics